Skip to the content

Your Local New Castle Independent Insurance Agency

M&M Insurance specializes in Auto/Car Insurance, Home Insurance, Business/Commercial Insurance, and Life/Health Insurance.

M&M Insurance and its affiliate Susan McConnell & Associates is an Independent Insurance Agency located in New Castle, Pennsylvania. We offer a full line of insurance products and specialties, including Auto/Car Insurance, Home Insurance, Business/Commercial Insurance, and Life/Health Insurance.

We are committed to the principles of service, integrity and professionalism with the goal of exceeding the expectations of our valued clients.

Insure Today…Secure Tomorrow!

Molly McConnell
Office Greeter
Read what satisfied customers have said about M&M Insurance.
See All Reviews
See All Reviews

Find Out How Much You Can Save Today

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Auto Insurance

Paying too much for auto insurance? With our flexible coverage options and expert service, you’ll know your vehicle is getting the best protection possible.
Get Coverage

Home Insurance

Your home is your greatest investment, but you shouldn’t have to break the bank to insure it. Find out how much we can save you on your homeowner policy today.
Get Coverage

Business Insurance

As a business owner, you have enough on your mind without having to worry about insurance needs. Let us find the best coverage at the best rates for you.
Get Coverage

Life Insurance

We offer a complete line of life insurance products that are crafted to meet you and your family's specific needs, giving you the coverage and benefits you want.
Get Coverage
white-logo-erie

ERIE's YourTurn® Program

There is a new way Erie Insurance is looking out for you and wants to help you stay safe on the road.
Learn More

Recent News & Updates

When Should I Call My Insurance Agent?

Posted: August 4, 2026

An insurance agent isn’t just someone who can sell you a policy. Whether you have a question about your coverage, need to file a claim or change your policy, your agent can provide insurance solutions to a seemingly countless number of issues you might run into. And the conversations you have with your agent can help provide protection from the unknown and greater peace of...

​What to Do After a Hit and Run​

Posted: August 4, 2026

Getting in a car accident is enough to ruin anyone's day. But if you’re involved in a hit-and-run, the experience can be especially disorienting. You realize that your vehicle’s been hit and before you can step out to get the other driver’s information, their car is taking off into the distance. As overwhelming as the experience can be, how you react next can play an...

Myths & Facts About Pumping Gas

Posted: July 5, 2026

For some reason, pumping gas tends to produce a lot of misconceptions. For instance, many people mistakenly believe that filling up in the morning at the day’s lowest temperature can put more gas in your tank. For the facts on this myth and others, continue reading. Facts and myths at a glance Don't smoke while pumping gas. Avoid distractions like texting while fueling. Stay outside...

Grilling Safety Tips for Propane, Charcoal and Gas Grills

Posted: June 29, 2026

Grilling food outside is a classic summer pastime but it’s not without risk. According to the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), grills are involved in more than 10,000 home fires per year. This guide helps explain common grilling risks, shares best safety practices and outlines the steps you can take in an emergency. Where should you place your grill? Placing your grill in an open,...

Specializing In Erie Insurance

Erie Insurance has been helping customers since 1925 with their auto, home, business, and life insurance needs.
Click here to get an auto insurance quote with Erie Insurance "ERIE Auto Insurance Quote" (opens in new tab)
Click here to pay your Erie Insurance bill "ERIE Pay Your Bill" (opens in new tab)
Click here to use the Erie Insurance Life Insurance Calculator "ERIE Life Insurance Calculator" (opens in new tab)